Questionnaires ranged from one word answers and tick box questions to long answered questions, this produced a varied array of quantitative and qualitative data in which I could compare.
Below are an array of the questionnaires completed by individuals; they provide a variation of questions which are; tick box questions, multiple choice and the participants own opinions, this allowed for instant feedback on any aspects of my music video I may need to edit/remove/add.
Another reason for using an large variety of questions was because individuals in my class would have been adapted to understand and view things from a different angle to those not in my class, a key example of this is the question, How does the music video use genre conventions? Those in my class would already be aware of what conventions would be expected of particular genre types in detail, where as those outside of the class would not have as keen of a eye to pick up where we have applied a convention to the scenario.
The first 4 questions all provided very similar results, the first question; did you enjoy the music video, the results included one 4 and five 5's, 1 being Bad and 5 being Good, this provided a very broad idea with little detail but still showed that the viewer enjoyed the music video. The next question, did it hold your attention, although yet again very broad and crosses over slightly with the first question, I could see if the individual with engaged with the production piece; the results produced two 4's and four 5's, although one marked slightly lower on this question they still showed as being engaged and I however had further detailed questions in which they could highlight what they viewed negatively. The next question, was the music video; too long, too short, correct, all participants answered correct. And finally, would you watch the music video again, all answered yes, this therefore showed me that the music video was interesting and had elements that kept the viewer hooked.
Above shows one of the questionnaire completed in the process, the first question answered, How does the music video use genre conventions? The individual states how I have used certain shots to the beat such as the young girl running down the stairs and drumming to the beat, this is a convention of the Pop genre and also applies to Goodwin's theory. She also says that the camera work and editing was effective in the next question, I believe this may have been one of the more difficult questions to answer, especially for those who have not been taught to notice how camera angles can create a whole different scene. What are your favourite shot/shots? This question was one based solely on the individuals preferences, in this case their favourite shot was of the shadow spinning on the grass, this shot provided the feel of freedom the young girl received from the outside world in a very simple shot which still provided great effect. I liked the shot and thought it went well with the portion of the song and so by receiving this response it only heightened my belief in this shot. She then goes onto say she understands the storyline, this question holds much greater power than the other questions as the music video is a narrative piece, it is very important that the viewer understands what is happening and therefore is able to relate to the piece. What did you dislike about the music video? The participant states she dislikes the strong use of black and white throughout the piece, I understood why the participant said this however, the use of black and white was chosen at the very beginning of production and was something we knew we would never change throughout the piece, alas when it came to editing we did view what the piece would look like in colour but quickly decided against it as it went "cheesy" and more into the Pop genre instead of being a mesh of both Pop and Alternative.
Although Beyonce "If I Were A Boy" is of the genre Pop and also shot in black and white, the production is polished and the black and white works well with it however, one of themain themes of this video is the pain that the woman is feeling, this corresponds with ours even though it is a different pain. This shows that black and white can work well within the Pop genre depending on the theme and the storyline.The use of black and white also highlighted the key theme of pain and the side of good and bad, in colour these themes wouldn't have been able to be highlighted in multiple contexts. And finally, How could I improve the music video? The answer was corresponding with the above answer, have certain scenes in colour for example the part where she is happy, this is a good idea as it would allow viewers to clearly visualise what the character was feeling emotionally nonetheless, I believe changing the colour effect on just a few shots would change the feel of the video too much, to something that was more theatrical than something highlighting this girls pain and freedom she then rightfully earns. After carrying out the questionnaire I asked the participant whether overall they enjoyed the piece and found the theme to be carried out in the correct manner, they agreed and said that the theme was carried out professionally without being violent/explicit a different kind of pain was shown which isn't very often in music videos.
The next participant also female, 18 years old, this fits the age of the demographic we wished to reach out to with our music video and also, I asked more females than males about the music video as the protagonist was a young girl going through this pain and therefore they are more likely to relate to her. The main question I wanted to highlight about this questionnaire; what are your favourite shot/shots. The participant answered with the flashing lights and the fireplace, these were two very important scenes to the production piece and therefore gaining this response was rewarding.
The shots taken of the young girl sitting amongst the lamps as they flash on and off both in sync and out of sync were shots decided upon very early on in production, originally with a slightly different concept they were altered slightly to adapt to a more adequate and realistic location, they provide a normal setting with a peculiar concept happening on around the young girl, the lamps. These shots were ones we believed to be strong and really capture audiences to keep watching, this is why the shot was used more than once throughout the piece, receiving the respond confirmed that these shots were used in a correct manner. The other strong shots noted were the fireplace shots, these were important to the piece as they provided one of the four elements in which we had used, the young girl is seen looking into the fire, this occurs within many family homes and yet the viewer can immediately sense that something is not right within this young girls. This shows that what we believed to be our strongest shots were and provided the themes and elements we wished for.
A participants questionnaire presented above, 18 and male, although in the same age range I wanted to view what a male's opinions were on the production piece.
How does the music video use genre conventions? Noted down are black and white, lighting and unhappy family. The effect of using black and white was taken from the Alternative genre, it provided something raw and allowed the piece to become more realistic while also seeming a little dated. The use of lighting is something that comes a lot more from the Pop genre, lighting is a major theme which is constantly mutated and is very rarely natural lighting, in our music video the only lighting trying adapted was the lamp scene. The unhappy family is a theme seen in the Alternative genre as they present real life scenarios and therefore we have moulded this convention into our own. According to the individuals feedback we have clearly represented our genre conventions in the video of both Alternative and Pop.
How effective was the camera work and editing? "great, the spinning shots with the cutaways." I found that these shots split up the scenes and provided something interesting, they distorted the viewers vision on what was happening within the scene, I hoped that this view would be seen by the audience as well and so it has.
Did you understand the storyline? As mentioned earlier this question is of heavy importance due to the narrative structure, "family arguing with the girl, girl runs away to a happy place." The answer given to this question simplifies what is happening throughout the video, this shows that the audience member was engaged with the piece and interpreted what was happening in the correct manner, this also shows that we managed to interpret the storyline of the video accurately.
Throughout the process of designing and making my Digipalk I was constantly asking others for their views on my ideas, I received feedback verbally. I asked my partner on my music video, Holly Duffield, for her opinions on my original concept for my Digipak, we both choose to design two very different pieces when it came to our Digipak, originally she liked the idea of body parts emerging from the darkness when I then presented the idea on photoshop she didn't like the idea, she believed it to be simple in the wrong manner.
I then moved forward with my other idea, I asked others outside of the class what they liked and disliked about it, at this point my front image was the same but with a plain black background, Rachael McCarney liked the image but believed the background to be too harsh and plain against the image, after some consideration and looking at the image I found this to be true and went onto change it.























